Karate vs taekwondo reddit. Just done differently.

Karate vs taekwondo reddit Because google sees Tae Kwon Do as 3 separate words, it gets confused, and makes it more difficult for people to find websites. Norb untrained street fighter: Things his roundhouse punch could beat anybody in the world. It heavily depends on the trainer, though. Pros include developing impressive dexterity and flexibility and, a "traditional" approach, if that's Taekwondo, originating from Korea, emphasizes speed and agility with spectacular high kicks and rapid striking techniques. For those seeking to master ground techniques, Jiu Jitsu may be the ideal choice. Especially if you spar. TKD usually goes for a speed motion, because the sparring is built around points. I believe Karate is no K. I never really thought about Hapkido being on the opposite spectrum as TKD, but I the more I think about it the more I think you are right. Thinks they could beat up any "pussy karate guy". The biggets difference between ITF, KKW, and ATA is mostly politics. Same moves. ) doesn't suffer from this. Honestly, I view Taekwondo and Karate as about the same in combat effectiveness (assuming that you train it for the sole purpose of doing full contact). The reason they look similar at all is because the roots of where these kicks come from trace back to CMAs. sreiches • +1 - ITF Taekwondo is a sniper game, Kyokushin Karate is an endurance game. yeah, ever since the heavy push to make TKD an olympic event in 1988, so many TKD schools popped up teaching only olympic sport which is not even close to indicative of TKD as a whole. ) @ K-1 GP FINAL +1 - Thanks to for the shoutout. If, by the way, the TKD/karate guy can check low kicks, you are in for a long day. Please be aware of the rules below. TKD was made from the Japanese occupation of Korea where the Japanese forced the Koreans to learn karate. Karate is far too variable to be described concisely. I’m biased since I do karate myself, but you have to find a good dojo. Shotokan Karate will teach you to use both your hands and feets, but if you want it to work in self defense situations, you have to make sure that there is spar sessions in your dojo. The only reason TKD is then not considered acceptable to be called karate is because of the politics behind TKD and the disdain the Koreans had for the Japanese during the unification of taekwondo. This thread is archived New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Or check it out in the app stores The differences between karate, judo, kung fu, ninjitsu, jiu jitsu, tae kwan do, and aikido? Culture 5 years of TKD under a 9 Dan who's stories of TKD history only reached back 3 masters from him before it got back to karate. Hơi lạ nhưng tôi có học qua và thấy karate khắt khe hơn nhiều về cái tinh thần võ đạo và sự chuẩn xác với các tư thế. I was taught Hapkido through my taekwondo masters for many years. The speed motion focuses on the chamber and on what's going on with the foot. And other TKD people that get offended at that concept. TKD only has kicks, by my understanding. I think it's like trying to decide between a Mustang and a Camaro, when another art may be a Fire Truck or a Prius. My main options are karate or bjj or Taekwondo. One rule breach will be a warning, two will be a 7 day ban, three will be permanent ban. Kyokushin is going to be miles different from "traditional" Shotokan, which will be different again from Okinawan styles, etc. So if you wanna learn to fight, don't learn tkd. They also tend to do a lot of really tough conditioning. That's also true for Taekwondo, at least the original Taekwondo (not the modern olympic one). There is a myth that it also incorporates a Korean martial arts Taekkyon, but there is little that suggests that as the kicks used can all be found in karate. A Tai Chi background will help you against an untrained fighter, but a MMA trained fighter would wreck anyone that does Tai Chi Tai Chi is an internal martial art/Yin style. But I definitely picked stuff up quicker than people with no trianing before so it wasn't a detriment. Muay Thai, gung fu, karate, then TKD. Edit: For what it's worth I have been doing karate for over 20 years and have a lot of experience sparring TKD dudes. For what purpose? I did both but tkd for over 20 years. Norb untrained Incel ATA vs Virgin World Taekwondo vs Brad boxing vs Chad ITF vs Thad kickboxing. Controversial. Karate is actually a family of marital arts which includes several styles such as Shotokan, Wado Ryu and Takewondo. For practitioners of the Korean martial art of Taekwondo. Judo will teach you how to grapple both in the clinch and on the ground, countless ways to throw someone on to the ground, a few basic submissions, how to defend against takedowns and how to fall safely. it is a rare martial art, some taekwondo schools may teach Hapkido in a limited form as a self defense to their black belts. ) The difference is that kickboxing is tried and tested and legit. Karate or Taekwondo . Did karate and taekwondo growing up, when I started training muay thai there were some things to adjust; less bladed stance, weight distribution, hip rotation etc. O. Premium Powerups Explore Taekwondo vs Karate | ITF vs WT | Reaction Commentary EP#1. Most TKD and karate guys do not have good hands. Related For practitioners of the Korean martial art of Taekwondo. For practitioners of the Korean martial art of Taekwondo View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Members Online • secarynights. A boxer keeps his guard up because he is defending against an attack coming from shoulder level. youtube. Include ju jitsu, boxing, and tkd are a great mix. A really brutal version of sen-no-sen. A TKD practitioner is (rarely) defending against an attack that originates from low. Dekkers, Sakmonkol, Zambidis. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. ADMIN MOD apparently karate "black belt" vs taekwondo "black belt" street fight. Members Online Taekwondo takes longer to train in, but is as rewarding at the end of it, and Taekwondo fighters can be very physical and strong. Anyways, I love Kyokushin Karate and Muay Thai because they seem so powerful and awesome. If they don't think you're going to hurt them with something, they'll just eat it and close in with their own damage. Taekwondo (WT) has been made a national issue, unifying most Korean Martial Art schools with Japanese origins under one roof organization and "koreanize" it. I think that tkd gets more flack than the other styles you mentioned because it's more popular than at least 2 of those and because the other, shotokan karate, is only one style Here in my place almost just these two kind of fighting style are available, but when i visit karate center i thought it was the same of Karate and taekwondo are two common and widely practiced forms of martial arts. Okinawan karate and Songahm taekwondo for weapons. Business, Economics, and Finance A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related. Related Topics As a taekwondo practitioner, taekwondo has better kicks, SpunkyDred is a terrible bot instigating arguments all over Reddit whenever someone uses the phrase apples You will probably find more differences between two TKD schools or between two Karate schools than between the average TKD and Karate school. Second Dan in TKD and literally most second year BJJ could easily defend themselves against a black belt in TKD with ease. I think the Taekwondo spelling may be easier for browser search engines to understand. In theory in the old days karate was a self defense art focused on getting in close and striking your opponent, throwing or escaping if they got too close. I've known TKD people that call it karate. Mấy người học karate nhìn vừa mạnh mẽ vừa điềm tĩnh. It's true that TKD is more kick heavy and loves kicks acrobatics way more, but I'm just not sure you have the right impression of karate. One rule breach will be a A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related. I did some research and Taekwondo and Tang Soo Do are essentially the same, mainly differing in name for historical reasons. I do Goju-Ryu and from my experience we have strikes with fists, elbows, knees and feet and takedowns as well and some joint submissions/attacks. I put karate second because, again, this is just my understanding, but karate has square mats for their fighting platforms, so a lot of karate practitioners try to chase each other off I’m doing a art wars series starting with Karate vs TKD. People can argue but it really is not even close. Valheim; Genshin Impact; Karate vs Taekwondo . from what i know, kyokushin is a pretty decent style and you will learn how to fight but as always, it’s never Taekwondo and karate split from each other in the 1940s and 1950s. Generally though, both are somewhere between a Martial Art and a Combat Sport, so they are both not primarily suited for self defense. Now TKD has this reputation as a non-functional martial art just because so many dojang decided to focus on the 5%-10% of the curriculum that is applicable to Olympic sparring and stopped Both kinds of TKD are heavily based on Shotokan Karate, so most of the very basics will be the same: Horse stance, punching from the hip, some basic blocks and such. Sure, Yilmaz fought Masato so that's one. Conversely, if you're drawn to kicking techniques and a dynamic sparring environment, Taekwondo might suit your style. And the Korean history makes it what it is. People that don't have the background are often slower, easier to hit, and very stuck in the punch combo, tepee, punch combo, leg kick modality. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related There are just as many, if nit more, differences internally between styles of karate or tkd as there are externally between karate at large and tkd at large; tkd is essentially just a grouping of yet more karate styles I love Karate and favor it, but lets be real if u find a dude in TKD who trains like kyokushin dudes do, he would do much better. Their kicks are lightning fast and they can do cool tricks, but that's about it. Soooooooo many more styles, it's ridiculous. Solid, dependable, but predictable style. Advertisement Coins. Kung Fu: Too many style choices to choose from, but mainly it's karate that flows a bit more naturally. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Members Online. soundly Taekwondo on the other hand Do means "way" literally, and is a philosophical school of thought from the orient founded by a figure "Lao Zi". I feel like boxing and taekwondo are pretty complementary too. So taekwondo is much more kick focused than karate, though karate does still kick a lot. Or Taekwondo vs Karate Do you think the higher stance of TKD makes our kicks faster? instagram. Shotokan karate is a great striking art. Karate: Kick/punch your way to victory. Open comment sort options. My experience is that the striking and kicking drills seem to reasonably on par with each other depending on the school, and true grappling drills are almost non-existent in the majority Honestly when someone says they train karate it’s usually not full contact karate. Probably more variation within arts than between them on average. In practice modern karate is at best fencing with the hands and feet leading to a very mobile sniper-esque style. People knew what karate was but not taekwondo. Like Sensei Mas Oyama said - "The heart of our karate is real fighting. Even with the snapping motion, there's a difference between a speed and power version. ITF TaeKwonDo will give you a good mixture of point Karate and American Kickboxing sparring. For practitioners of the Korean martial art of Taekwondo (WT/KKW, ITF or other independent groups - all are welcome) Please be aware of the rules below. Honestly, I've scored some solid shots on guys sparring using "karate-style" punching and some sharp kicks using TKD and Goju. Be the first to comment A black belt in Karate vs a black belt in Taekwondo vs a black belt in Judo vs a black belt in Kickboxing vs the equivalent of a black belt in Kung Fu The same average Joe is trained in all of these martial arts up until black belt or the equivalent and somehow they are all transferred to the same room to fight. if u want to ask who wins in a fight, that would all come down to the training of how good the master trains. That’s why In my opinion from someone who is trained taekwondo and kickboxing, a person with a year of solid boxing under their belt is much more of a put together fighter that someone with a year of karate or tae kwon do under their belt. I considered tkd more of a sport as compared to kyokushin was more geared towards real life scenario self defence. This has led to the ludicrious displays we are seeing in current TKD competition, which has all the force and power of a kindergarten game of tag. It's also easier to apply Karate than Wing Chun since it's better in most fighting ranges. Gaming. Im used to spelling it as Tae Kwon Do with spaces. ITF taekwondo for 2 on one sparring and to learn about the history of Korea. Some styles have evolved to become very different, and some styles of TKD have stayed very close to their karate roots. I can’t say ATA forms are better or worst than any other forms done by other taekwondo organizations. Literally TKD offers no takedown defense. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. Let's start with some basics: Kicks in goju Ryu are much less acrobatic and stability is View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. So I'll stick to the self defence mindful teachings of my ITF instructor, r/judo is a reddit for judoka and spectators to submit anything about Judo. If you're talking about karate broadly, you'll need to be more specific. Karate's roots trace back to white crane Kung Fu, and there was a ton of transfer of techniques between CMAs in history. You also do know that tornado kicks and 540s exist in karate right? YouTube search karate 540 kick, first result should be the karate guy. Boxing will make your hands heavier (even if you use TKD/Karate Muay Thai will be an extension of Kickboxing. I'm curious as to your reasoning for the advantages of karate over kung fu for any of the ranges you've mentioned, especially considering karate was born from a few of the Southern kung fu styles. I am 13 years old and I am wondering if what martial art I should do. IS the first thing people train against in any dojo. com IMO a better professional kickboxer from back in the day with a TKD background is Hassan Kassrioui. I liked the free flowing frequency of the kicks though. Karate will be at the 2020 games in Tokyo, and If you block out competition TKD and sport karate, and just focus on the two as combat arts, they're brothers under the skin as you'd expect, given the roots of early TKD in Karate vs Taekwondo: Exploring Their Differences. There’s also something to be said about the history and tensions between Japan and Korea, which certainly motivated the distinction between karate and taekwon-do. (I add 'rarely', because the standard TKD tactic is to counter-attack, as opposed to blocking. Wado karate for sword techniques and throws. Skip to Taekwondo Kickboxer vs Karate Kickboxer in Japan . I don’t think it’s as simple as whether one art is more useful than others, my Sensei always say there is no useless arts as long as you put the time and effort to realize it’s shortcomings in order to make it work. It's very heretical for a Karate Black Belt to say this, but katas have too much of their applications camouflaged in ancient Asian dance. Overall, you'll probably find more differences between two WT schools than you will between the average ITF school and average WT school. would you recommend taking the karate PE or taekwondo PE? I’m interested in possibly keeping the hobby for a long time :) I did karate for a year a few years back so I was thinking of continuing that, but I heard A LOT of good things about Cornell TKD both as a class and as a club, while hearing nothing about karate. It's unfair to reduce the whole systems down to their preference in technique - The big difference is in the philosophy. TKD officially uses electronic sensors in the foot/hand pads, and the hogu. " Similar to karate, but maybe a bit more focused on kicking. K-1 style kickboxing has its roots in Kyokushin karate and there were lots of matches between Thais and Kyokushin guys back in You'd be surprised the advantages that TKD and karate can give a person. Top. Nữ học cũng ổn vì karate không thiên nhiều về sức mạnh mà là sự chính xác của thế A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related. You are unlikely to find a Hapkido school in the U. Having just sparred five rounds against my instructor and another black belt tonight, I can attest that this is pretty much how they deal with TKD and Hapkido guys. Karate may provide some solid entries in sparring not found in the other ones. Tkd is a meme style that was stoles from karate, which is also a meme. Karate vs Tang Soo Do . Kukkiwon (World Taekwondo/WT sport rules), International Taekwon-do Federation(s) (ITF) or other independent groups - all are welcome. Compared to many other forms of karate there is a greater emphasis on sparring with full contact. Karate vs BJJ . Also I didn't really like taekwondo because it felt a lot like a ballet, and you barely use your hands for fighting. Most of teakwondo practictionners don't learn how to defend against punches, because of the rules of competitions. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. What makes difference is that Kyokushin still stays true to the purpose of martial arts. I personally love all the martial arts, karate, Jui jitsu, judo, or WT TKD. There's only slight differences between the two, relatively speaking. . Boxing teaches you to defend yourself but to be mindful of the other person too. Battle Both are equal in size, athleticism and skill Karate guy is a kyokushin fighter, Boxer uses a western style, r/judo is a reddit for judoka and spectators to submit anything about Judo. r/taekwondo. Taking out the spaces makes it easier for a computer to understand that its technically just 1 word. well, as someone who did karate it has been going pretty bullshit. I recommend looking up Nieky Holzken's fights against Raymond Daniels. Examples of good fighters in the ufc are conor mcgregor, anderson silva and athony pettis who all employ various accurate and powerful kicks that they learned from their base taekwondo and then Taekwondo is taekwondo, you may know it is kicking focus. I don't see karate as a self-defense technique. Taekwondo has the same problem (though a taekwondo user wouldn't do well after just one year anyway) if we're talking about WTF taekwondo. So tkd is technically harder, but also I'm sorry it's less effective because of 1. WT taekwondo if you want to learn fancy kicks and have a shot at the Olympics. Basically Kyokushin teaches a slightly different kicking style from MT that also works for full contact fighting, while TKD teaches a substantially different kicking style that can be adapted, but probably won't work right out of the box (substantially different footwork, emphasis on kicks that I would like r/martialarts opinion on this fight. As said in the title: An average Black Belt 1st Dan in Karate vs the equivalent in Tae-Kwondo vs equivalent in Kung Fu vs the equivalent in Judo No rules, battle royale, the winner wins when others are dead. The fighter can have a solid base and knowledge, but is less practical in applying it due to lack of experience in competition. Also, my summary of karate vs tkd: Tkd: more kicks, more cardio emphasis, more jumping and spinning Karate: more hand techniques, better patterns Sidenote: Don't be afraid of competition or sparring -- competition can build confidence and can help your child measure their accomplishments, and sparring can help with the application of the techniques Which Karate style? There is quite a variety of them. It's all taekwondo, if you really wanna get technical its all karate. Many of those differences will go away when you get more advanced and learn I have been practicing karate all my life, but have also did TKD for 4 years to help with some of my kicks. generally tho, i switched to taekwondo cause even tho karate has more hand movement the hand movement is often bull shit. Your best choice might be some full contact Karate style like Kyokushin etc. Tae-Kwon-Do: Means "Hands and feet together. Tang Soo Do is actually rather similar to Karate in many ways as it was influenced by the Japanese occupation of Korea. We taught the practical application of the forms. Traditional taekwondo (so various elements of Taekkyon, Subak etc. The term Korean karate was thrown around a lot in the 1980s. Also tkd instructors were the worst narcissts Ive encountered in a decade of martial arts Note: this is about effectiveness and self defense. Is karate better than taekwondo? As a taekwondo athlete myself i believe that karate is better. There's a flexibility aspect to tkd and moving in free space against another person in free space who can move in any direction adds a much higher level of complexity vs judo. My experience in multiple TKD schools is we learn both, but spar with speed. At its core Korean Taekwondo is karate in the same way kyokushin is karate. upvotes Karate vs Taekwondo vs Boxing vs Capoeira in a kickboxing tournament . However I quit due to exams and other passions. I wouldn't say that karate is useless; I think that it's just scary. I am lucky to train in it extensively. Compared to Aikido which nowadays is practically useless, if it ever did have merit it’s been watered down and diminished Karate is really inconsistent in terms of quality, while Judo is consistently great. and TKD you can hit as hard as you want. New. If we're talking WTF TKD compared to WKF karate, not much. Share Add a Comment. Basically what Taekwondo has been in the 70s. I found a small school near my house that teaches A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts r/taekwondo. TKD Kickboxing vs Karate Kickboxing. Taekwondo focus heavily on kicks and not on hands. In BJJ you know how to defend against strikes. tae kwon do has probably the widest variety both in style and and in quality, with a possible contender in karate for pretty much the same exact reason (though I'd still argue tkd takes the gold here - I've seen tkd in the modern day that is strikingly similar to their karate roots, but not karate that looks strikingly similar to other styles of tkd). Old. Karate and taekwondo are among the most popular martial arts globally, each offering unique philosophies, techniques, They are very similar in most cases, unfortunately, and as such share similar pros and cons. For practitioners of the Korean martial art of Taekwondo (WT/KKW, ITF or other independent groups - all I'm enjoying the TKD patterns MUCH more than Karate Kata, because their content and application are far more natural than Karate katas. On top of that, TKD has several sub-classes including WTF and ITF. Sort by: Best. The difference between the two martial arts are fundamental and each has it's place in the world of the arts. Karate. (WTF style sparring) In Karate you stop fighting after a point is scored, in TKD you keep going and can score more points with combination kicks. TKD and karate are very very similar. Taekwondo was just korean karate and then over time it became its own thing, but at the root its still just karate. For starters WT is just a governing body for the olympic TKD sport and not a governing body for rank in a TKD style, for that you want Kukkiwon. Hapkido and tae kwon do aren't considered to be "karate". Just done differently. The rest is probably politics. Makes sense since taekwondo came out of shotokan karate. If you like the school, stick with it. Choosing between Jiu Jitsu, Taekwondo, and Karate often depends on personal interests and training goals. There can be no proof without real fighting. This registers the strike as long as it touches. One is about punching and the other is about focusing on kicks. r/judo is a reddit for judoka and spectators to submit anything about Judo. The same for karate. S. Q&A. I want to do a fighting sport, but I don’t know where to start and what to choose, I’ve seen some videos on YouTube but that only made me more questionable. Don't worry, I was just looking for a comparison between Karate, Hapkido and TKD. 0 coins. Conversely, Karate, which comes from Japan, focuses more on hand techniques, deep stances, Just look at the previous Olympics. They’re so popular, in fact, that both are now Olympic Sports. You can think of it as a nature school that tries to harmonize ones being with the universe. im a first degree black belt in taekwondo, and the main difference between the both is that taekwondo places more emphasis on kicking and leg techniques, whereas karate is more focused on hand techniques. TKD is primarily Shotokan Karate with a bit of a traditional Korean kicking art mixed in (Taekkyeon). Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. Idris Elba's Professional Kickboxing fight and the sparring he did in preparation for it 8:47. Taekwondo teaches more kicks, but many of the kicks taught are less optimized for full-contact. Its martial application is greatly limited compared to traditional Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 13 votes and 5 comments My main options are karate or bjj or Taekwondo. If it leads to good discussions I may post more VS fights similar to this If a fighter is taught both sport taekwondo and traditional taekwondo (similar in basis to some types of karate) a taekwondo fighter can develop great speed, strength and agility. BJJ not even close. The next noticeable difference is the ruleset for their association specific tournaments and the forms they do. com Open. And you will likely learn to strike hard ans explosive. From what I've seen, Tang Soo Do is closer to the Japanese Karate origins than modern Taekwondo. Best. Honest, if it’s self defence, a mixture is best. tjkun Hey, thanks for your thoughts. I’ve always been curious about the comparisons between ancient asian martial arts. In any case, what most people know about Kyokushin Karate Taekwondo VS Muay Thai (K. 32K subscribers in the taekwondo community. He fought some legends. Beat up some ATA yellow belt from a 3rd ring A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Old school TMA's were harder with their conditioning and Kyokushin was born out of Muay Thai and Karate, big difference is pro Thai gyms are more common than pro Taekwondo or Karate gyms. There are no punches to the head though. karate is now deemed a none contact sport. Discussion Is Karate more effective than Taekwondo? How do the strikes and kicks compare? Are the techniques much different? Share The Korean martial artists disagree with this I know, mostly for political reasons, but for the sake of ease and classification, it's best to look at Hopkido as a Korean Jujutsu, and as TSD and TKD as Korean Karate. But my life isn't long enough to master 1 discipline, let alone 2. ytvwsp zfyf wfr asd xtvryl czzydldh ahiorzg aagxgv vimvt ybomdt